The World According to Mitch

The day-to-day ramblings of an IT Trainer and Community Leader

News

blogs.mitchgarvis.com is now live and populated!

Vista - Fact or Fiction?

For more information about the Windows Springboard Series visit http://go.microsoft.com/?linkid=8418918

As the old saying goes, if I had a dime for every person who has come up to me and told me why they are not moving to Windows Vista, I would be a rich man.  The problem is that most of those reasons are just not true.  There seem to be enough myths surrounding Vista to fill a textbook.  Over the next few weeks I am going to address many of them in the hopes of dispelling some of the falsehoods and hopefully convincing some of the doubtfuls to give Vista a try.

The one issue that I know IS very real is the cost... so I'll make you a deal: If you post your issues as a comment to one of my articles then you just may win one of five copies of Windows Vista Ultimate to install on your PC!

So let's pick a single arbitrary myth to discuss here: hardware compatibility.

In the beginning there were a whole lot of computers running Windows XP with any number of peripherals, such as scanners and printers.  When Windows Vista was released many people decided it was the right time to either upgrade their existing computers, or in some cases purchase new ones.  Unfortunately many of them (including my mother) had older peripheral devices (in my mother's case it was an inkjet printer, but it would go for scanners and all manner of other devices) that did not have device drivers available.  Blame Vista.

It might not occur to everyone, but Microsoft does not write device drivers... well, except for Microsoft Hardware which creates the drivers for its own products.  It's true, there were hardware manufacturers slow out of the gate to get proper drivers written, and especially in the first few months there was a simple rule: the older your device, the worse your chances of finding a driver for it.  Indeed, to this day I am not certain that hardware manufacturers did not withhold drivers for older devices in the hopes that consumers would buy new ones. 

How often has Vista crashed on your computer?  I can count on one hand how often I have seen a BSOD (Blue Screen of Death) on Windows Vista.  Care to guess the root cause of each and every one?  If you guessed Device Drivers then you get the prize!  Again, while Microsoft can write the most stable code possible, and then provide guidelines to hardware manufacturers, it is simply not possible to regulate and test every driver.  That is why signed drivers are always a better idea than unsigned drivers.  When I was beta testing Vista on my Media Center PC I had terrible problems with BSODs until the video card manufacturer released an updated driver.  The moment they did my Media Experience has been a smooth ride.

Let me be clear here about one thing.  I am not going to be an apologist for Microsoft with respect to Windows Vista.  I like the product - I do prefer it to Windows XP - while realizing there are downsides to it.  As a very early beta tester I have now had nearly three years to get used to it, and did so to the point that when I go back to Windows XP - an OS I used to know like the back of my hand - I often pause to remember 'the old ways'.  I had no such issues going from Windows 2000 to XP and back, because they were so similar; indeed, XP was written on top of Windows 2000.  That is not the case with Vista, which has been rewritten from scratch.  A lot of legacy issues and inefficiencies that date back three versions or more are gone, while building in a level of both stability and security previously unheard of in Windows.

The problem then is that when rewriting the operating system several things were done differently.  Microsoft is not the first company to move things around for comfort, efficiency, and logic; remember the old gear shifts behind the steering wheel in cars? 

Of course, the gearshift being a physical handle it was easier to  look down and see a new handle where the bench seat used to go across and make the connection.  So many features in Windows Vista are much harder to find, so (in what I consider a huge improvement) the Start Pearl now has a built-in live Search feature... if you are looking for the Display Properties, just type that in and it will pop up.

So now that I have covered a couple of Vista Myths, tell me about yours... why aren't you deploying yet?  Make it good and you might win a copy of Vista to try out for yourself!  Just leave a comment below and make sure I have your e-mail address... I will try to answer all questions, either in reply comments or in future articles, and hopefully help out one or two converts ;)

Comments

Video X Drivers » Vista - Fact or Fiction? said:

Pingback from  Video X Drivers » Vista - Fact or Fiction?

# May 1, 2008 10:50 AM

Rami Negev said:

To begin with yes there is the Price factor.  At $500 plus tax for the Ultimate Edition it is a bit hefty for those of us who want to get ALL the features that Vista has to offer.

Hardware compatibility-

I found that my Printer will not be supported on the new operating system and will never be supported as HP has decided my Printer is just too old.  (I had the same problem when moving to XP from (dare I say it) ME.  Thankfully HP at that time was nice enough to provide a driver that did connect to the printer but only via the parallel port.  the USB port never managed to connect to the printer properly even though the function was clearly marked in the driver installation. (Ironically it will connect via the USB on a Linux machine without a driver installation file, but I digress).

When I was running the evaluation copy of vista it was not compatible with my TV-Tuner in my All-in-Wonder so I'm not so sure about the full version or if the issue has been addressed.

I also found that my machine was only just bairly capable of handling the OS. some of the higher functions were  not available to me.  So I suppose it is time to upgrade but that could be pricey at the moment.

I also found it too cumbersome for trouble shooting purposes though it is possible to get to many of the functions I am used to on XP within Vista.

I am also not so sure that some of the software (older) that I own might not run on Vista (I have not had the chance to try).

 <Reply from MDG> I understand that a lot of hardware manufacturers are not writing new drivers for MUCH older printers... that is a business decision they made, assumingly to get you to buy a new printer from them.  My mother had that issue and she did buy a new printer...but as a message to the manufacturer, she bought it from someone else.

As for the versions, you are right... 'everyone wants the Ultimate Edition,' which is more expensive.  When I bought my car I wanted the 4-wheel-drive sports package with the sunroof and MP3 player... and decided the price difference was not within my budget.  If you are not joining a domain then try Home Premium for all the features including Media Center.  If you need a domain-joined machine go for Business Edition, for the complete functionality of Windows XP Professional.

As for the older software that you have not had opportunity to test yet, I will contact you off-line and get a shiny new copy of Vista to you for testing... let us know how it goes!

# May 1, 2008 4:10 PM

Topic Drivers » Vista - Fact or Fiction? said:

Pingback from  Topic Drivers &raquo; Vista - Fact or Fiction?

# May 1, 2008 10:11 PM

Vista - Fact or Fiction? » Lilu Drivers Blog said:

Pingback from  Vista - Fact or Fiction?  &raquo;  Lilu Drivers Blog

# May 2, 2008 12:23 AM

Heath said:

the reason why i haven't yet deployed vista is because it won't run of half of my systems. the hardware requirements of vista are too great. now that sp1 is out i will look at deploying on new systems.

 <Reply from MDG> Will your systems NOT RUN Vista, or will it not run Vista with Aero and other effects?  I know of a lot of companies (and individuals, my son included!) whose computers did need a bit more memory, but in lieu of replacing the video card we just disabled Aero and it works like a charm!

# May 2, 2008 8:18 AM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required)